How to Choose the Best Alternative to Stripe Billing for Your Startup

August 23, 2023
Stripe Billing is a popular billing solution for SaaS startups, known for its ease of use, powerful features, and seamless integrations. However, it may not always be the perfect fit for every business, especially for high-growth SaaS startups. In this article, we'll discuss why you might consider alternatives to Stripe Billing, key features to look for in an alternative, how to evaluate different solutions, and some top alternatives to consider for your SaaS startup.

When to Use Stripe Billing

Stripe Billing is an excellent fit for simple SaaS products with limited features and a fixed pricing model, such as a product with only two features sold at the same price. Its straightforward integration, ease of use, and setup speed make it a reliable choice for managing subscriptions and billing for such products on an ongoing basis.
A great example of a product that would be a good fit for Stripe Billing, given its simplicity and fixed pricing model, is a project management tool with only two features: task management and team collaboration. This tool would be sold at a flat rate per user, with no additional pricing tiers or add-ons.
However, if you have anything that’s even a little bit more complicated than that, it might end up causing more headaches than it’s worth; so here is what you should look out for when looking for Stripe Billing alternatives.

Why Stripe Billing Might Not Be Enough

Depending on the complexity of your SaaS business and its pricing, Stripe Billing might not offer enough nuance and complexity to support your business, especially as you scale and your needs evolve. Let's look at that in more detail.
Stripe Billing's pricing structure, which includes a percentage-based fee on each transaction, may not be the most cost-effective option for your business. This can be especially true if your SaaS product has a high transaction volume, unique pricing models, or requires custom features that may incur additional costs.
Geographical Limitations
Stripe may not support certain currencies or be available in specific regions where you wish to do business. This can limit your ability to effectively serve customers in those markets and may require you to find Stripe alternatives that support a wider range of currencies and regions.
If your SaaS product requires a highly customizable billing solution to accommodate unique pricing models, billing scenarios, or complex subscription management, Stripe Billing may not offer the level of customization you need. In such cases, you may need to explore the best Stripe alternatives that provide more flexibility and customization options.
Payment Gateway Limitations
Stripe's recurring billing platform primarily supports card payments through the Stripe payment gateway. If your business requires support for multiple payment gateways, mobile payments, multiple payment options, or simply prefers to use a different gateway due to factors like lower transaction fees or better market penetration, you may need to consider alternative billing solutions that offer more flexibility in terms of payment processing options.
No White-Labeling Options
Stripe Billing does not offer white-labeling options for its checkout pages or customer portal. If your SaaS business requires a fully branded billing experience, you may need to explore other billing solutions that provide white-labeling capabilities.
No Native Support for Usage-Based Billing
If your SaaS product relies on usage-based billing models, such as pay-per-use or metered billing, Stripe Billing may not be the best fit. While it's possible to implement usage-based billing using Stripe's API, it requires custom development and may not be as streamlined as solutions that natively support such billing models.
Migration Complexity
If you're considering migrating from an existing billing solution to Stripe Billing, the migration process can be quite hard, particularly if you have a large customer base or data scattered all over many different silots. The migration may require custom development and extensive planning to ensure a seamless transition to the new solution, which could be distracting, especially if you have limited technical resources or tight timelines.

Key Features to Look for in an Alternative

There are plenty of things to watch out for when evaluating alternatives. We listed some of the most important ones below.
Pricing Flexibility
Look for a billing solution that supports various pricing models, such as per-seat, usage-based, tiered, or hybrid pricing, to cater to your specific business needs and target customer segments.
Multi-Currency Support
Ensure the alternative supports multiple currencies and provides automatic currency conversion to cater to international customers, making it easier for them to understand and compare pricing.
Integration Capabilities
The billing solution should easily integrate with your existing systems, such as CRM, accounting, and customer support tools, to streamline your business processes and ensure seamless data sharing.
Choose a billing solution that can grow with your business, accommodating increasing transaction volumes and expanding product offerings, without compromising performance or customer experience.
Security and Compliance
The best alternatives adhere to industry security standards and support compliance with regulations such as GDPR and PCI DSS, ensuring the protection of your customers' data and your business's reputation.
Self-Serve Frontend Components
If you want to make your life (and that of your engineers) easier, you should look for a billing solution that offers self-serve frontend components, such as customizable customer portals and checkout pages, allowing customers to manage their accounts, subscriptions, and billing information independently.
Auto Update Pricing Pages
Choose a billing solution that automatically updates pricing pages based on changes in your pricing models or currencies, ensuring accurate and up-to-date information for your customers.
Churn Reduction Analytics
Opt for a billing solution that provides analytics and insights into customer churn, helping you identify trends, potential issues, and opportunities for improvement to reduce churn and retain customers.
Payment Options
A diverse range of payment options is essential to cater to customer needs and ensure a smooth transaction process. Look for a billing solution that supports multiple payment methods, such as credit card payments, debit card payments, PayPal payments, Apple Pay, Amazon Pay, and other popular digital wallets for online payments, as well as accommodates recurring and one-time payments. Providing a variety of payment options can improve customer satisfaction and potentially boost conversion rates.
Upsell Automations
A billing solution with built-in upsell automation features (hint: there not that many) can help you identify and capitalize on upselling opportunities, such as offering upgrades or add-ons to customers based on their usage patterns or preferences, all of which lead to revenue growth for you.
If your SaaS business provides custom pricing or you negotiate deals with each of your customers, look for a billing solution that supports quoting and proposal management, streamlining the sales process and ensuring accurate invoicing.

By considering these expanded features in your search for an alternative billing solution, you can find a platform that not only addresses your basic billing needs but also supports your business's growth, customer experience, and revenue optimization goals.

Evaluating Stripe Competitors

Do Research if All Your Requirements are Met: Before committing to a recurring billing solution, thoroughly research its features, functionality, and compatibility with your specific requirements.
Check if You Have Internal Engineering Resources Available
Assess the technical resources available within your organization to ensure a smooth implementation and integration of the billing solution with your existing systems.
Assess Customer Support
Evaluate the level of customer support offered by the billing solution provider, ensuring they provide timely and knowledgeable assistance.
Calculate Total Cost of Ownership
Compare the pricing of different billing solutions, considering factors such as setup fees, transaction fees, and any additional costs for premium features.

As you evaluate potential billing solutions, it's crucial for you to thoroughly examine the technical documentation to ensure that your exact use case is supported without requiring extensive internal development efforts. Many SaaS companies face unexpected complications and more work for their team to accommodate their specific use case when implementing a new billing solution. By carefully reviewing the technical documentation and confirming compatibility with your requirements, you can find the right solution, save time, resources, and potential issues in the long run.

Anticipating Future Growth When Selecting a Stripe Billing Alternative

When evaluating alternatives to Stripe Billing, it's crucial to consider not only your current needs but also anticipate future growth and expansion. Choosing a subscription management and billing solution that can scale with your business and adapt to your evolving requirements is essential for long-term success. Here are some factors to consider when selecting a billing solution with future growth in mind:
Flexible Pricing Models
As your business grows, you may need to adjust your pricing strategy or introduce new pricing models. Look for a billing solution that supports a wide range of pricing models and allows for easy modifications to accommodate your changing business needs and allows you to sell to small businesses as well as large enterprise companies.
Expanding Geographical Reach
If you plan to expand beyond San Francisco into new international markets, ensure the billing solution supports multiple currencies, offers automatic currency conversion, and can handle region-specific tax regulations and compliance requirements.
Integration with Future Tools and Systems
As your business grows, you may need to adopt new tools and systems for managing various aspects of your operations. Ensure the billing solution you choose can easily integrate with new platforms, either through native integrations or a robust API.
Advanced Reporting and Analytics
As your customer base and transaction volume grow, having access to advanced reporting and analytics features in a simple user interface becomes increasingly important for making data-driven decisions. Look for a billing solution that provides detailed insights into customer behavior, revenue trends, and churn analysis.
Automation Capabilities
To keep up with the growing demands of your business, it's essential to automate processes and reduce manual tasks. Choose a billing solution that offers automation features, such as automated invoicing, dunning management, and upsell opportunities, to streamline your operations and improve efficiency. In addition, make sure that you can automate payments without being tied to a single payment method. Ideally, you should be able to support payment collection using credit card processing, but also PayPal payments, Amazon Pay, and other digital wallets.

Top Alternatives to Consider

Chargebee is a comprehensive subscription billing solution that supports multiple pricing models, currencies, and tax management. It offers seamless integrations with popular payment gateways and business tools.
Zuora is a robust billing and subscription management platform designed for businesses with complex pricing models and a need for high customization. It offers advanced analytics, revenue recognition, and tax compliance features.
Recurly is a flexible subscription billing platform that supports a wide range of pricing models and offers multi-currency support. It provides easy integration with popular payment gateways and business tools.
Paddle is a unified billing platform specifically designed for SaaS businesses, offering subscription management, multi-currency support, and tax compliance features. It also includes a built-in payment gateway.
Wingback is a comprehensive platform that specializes in B2B SaaS monetization including billing, pricing and packaging, subscription management and more. The platform’s unique approach handles monetization from feature-level plan editing to the line item on the invoice, also taking care of entitlements, usage-based pricing, metering, pricing experimentation and optimization, self-serve / signup, and automated invoicing. It also integrates with multiple payment gateways and accounting solutions.

Final Thoughts

While Stripe Billing is a great choice for SaaS businesses with straightforward, super-simple pricing models and no other conditions, it’s not the best fit for anything more complicated than that.

There are plenty of alternatives on the market that thrive where Stripe Billing won’t cut it. When considering alternatives, focus on finding a billing solution that offers pricing flexibility, multi-currency support, payment collection, seamless integrations, scalability, and robust security and compliance features.

By carefully evaluating your options and choosing the right billing solution for your needs, you can streamline your billing processes, cater to diverse customer segments, and support your business's growth.

Curious if Wingback may be the right fit? Book a call to learn more.
← Blog